Psychological first aid following the Haitian earthquake: Community support and education, not therapy

There has been a lot of talk among mental health professionals about the psychological consequences of the devastating earthquake that struck Port Au Prince, Haiti, two weeks ago, and just what should be done right now. The answer, it turns out, is not what you might expect.

Check out the National Center for PTSD’s “psychological first aid” suggestions. Their list is comprised of primarily educational measures. Notably, nowhere on the list of things to do in the first weeks following a disaster is psychotherapy as we traditionally think of it. Indeed, nowhere on the list is anything that needs to be done by mental health professionals. The suggestions are pretty much good common sense: seek emotional support from friends, family, religious and other community groups; maintain as predictable a routine as possible for your kids; and although you should stay informed, stay away from sensationalized media coverage. If people are acting anxious, that’s because they are distressed — and that’s normal following a disaster. For most people this distress will decrease when basic needs are satisfied and some measure of stability is reestablished.

This is not to say that mental health professionals should not volunteer their time to help in this crisis. They might work in Haitian communities to educate people about normal reactions, or even organize events to help raise money to rebuild hospitals and schools. An effective mental health professional’s expertise in immediate post-disaster contexts is limited to education. Sending American psychologists to Haiti to do mental health work is not worth the money, given that (1) this type of education can be done by people already there and (2) the resources they would take up in terms of their housing and sanitation would be a net draw on relief efforts.

Why can’t mental health professionals come up with something better than reassuring us to follow our common support mechanisms in immediate post-trauma contexts? Well, two answers: (1) We actually do have the beginnings of what to do in the immediate aftermath of trauma in recent pharmacotherapy research (e.g., previous blog entry), but it’s still pretty uncharted territory. In Haiti applying this research would be impractical in any case as hospitals were destroyed, let alone medications not being available. (2) Attempts to do “emergency psychotherapy” — like critical incident debriefing, which was big in the 1990s and used following 9/11 — have shown to actually over-sensitize people to trauma, resulting in higher rates of trauma-related problems later on. So, as we know that most people exposed to a trauma recover, and indeed, natural disasters result in some of lowest rates of PTSD relative to other types of trauma, our best bet at this point is to educate, and leave people to marshall their own psychological and community resources.

So, support relief efforts in Haiti — but let’s not send the shrinks just yet. They will be needed later on, when it becomes clear who is in the minority that suffers long-term distress. And let’s hope that the urge on the part of mental health professionals to do something hasn’t passed by then, as that’s exactly when it will be needed.

4 Responses to “Psychological first aid following the Haitian earthquake: Community support and education, not therapy”

  1. 1 Korey Thompson January 24, 2010 at 12:51 pm

    There also may be a mid-place in the scheme of how to address trauma for disaster victims. The use of energy meridian tapping techniques have been shown to provide relief from stress, they require no pharmacology resources or medical equipment, they are quick and easy to learn and are as close as ones own fingertips.

    Meridian tapping techniques work on the principle of acupuncture or acupressure by balancing energy meridian pathways throughout the body. It’s been found that tapping on only a few junctions of these energy pathways serves to signal the entire energetic system to bring it closer to balance. Tapping has already been successfully used with PTSD with vets to relieve stress.

    Early use of these techniques could support benefits from recommended “emotional support from friends, family, religious and other community groups; [maintaining] as predictable a routine as possible for your kids; and [staying]informed” by strengthening the ability to cope. If a portion of disorientation and distress from trauma is relieved, improved coping skills could ripple small comforts into communities to aid the process of rebuilding.

  2. 2 MB March 11, 2010 at 10:00 pm

    Is this still true – that there has been no effort to provide relief for trauma sufferers??

    • 3 andyrasmussen March 12, 2010 at 10:57 am

      In a larger sense, the entire Port Au Prince region has suffered trauma, so all relief efforts are responding to that trauma. There are few psychological relief efforts in the works, but psychological programs without basic needs taken care of is ineffective; thankfully, the psychological programs that are being planned are taking this into account.

  1. 1 Survive Now, Talk Later « Eric P. Green Trackback on January 22, 2010 at 9:51 am

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

January 2010
« Dec   Feb »

%d bloggers like this: