Placebo effects, traditional healers, and cross-cultural psychology

Placebo effects and non-evidence based practice (December 6 post) have direct relevance for cross-cultural psychology, including post-disaster mental health in non-Western contexts. There’s a healthy debate occurring in trauma psychology concerning the most appropriate modes of service delivery following mass violence. Specifically, the debate revolves around whether disaster mental health professionals s should upport traditional (or at least local) healing or import Western psychological practices into the local context.

First, a few basics. When psychologists talk about traditional healing, they usually mean the treatments applied by traditional healers, locally-identified experts specific to the cultural context in which they are working. So, for example, in eastern Chad where there are lots of refugees from Darfur, traditional healers are marabouts, or fakir, people who have studied healing practices, including the use of local medicinal plants and spiritual practices (e.g., incantation of verses from the Koran, for instance). You can include Inuit shamans, Tibetan emchis, etc. in this category. In general, traditional healers are usually thought of as separate from medical and psychological professionals trained in Western medicine. In other words, they are “culturally bounded.” (Of course, the reality is that traditional healers may integrate many aspects of Western medicine, and may even be Western-trained professionals who use culturally-bounded practices as well as those they learned in their Western professional training.)

Usually we think of traditional healing as easy to “respectfully dismiss,” as clearly it’s not evidence based… right? Well, actually, there is some evidence supporting traditional healing. Joop de Jong, one of the founders of the global Transcultural Psychiatry Organization, presented some evidence just over a year ago that in a randomized clinical trial of counseling versus traditional healing in Burundi, the traditional healers had a much greater healing effect. In other words, traditional healing is evidence based practice for mental health problems (at least in Burundi). Of course you’ll want to know more about this study… but for that you’ll have to ask Joop.

So what does traditional healing have to do with the placebo effect? In the US, dismantling studies have shown that some 30-40% of the efficacy of therapy is just showing up for that first appointment. Patients have a belief – a culturally-grounded belief – that going to therapy is the right thing to do, so it works. This is essentially a placebo effect (of course, if you read the December 6 entry, you knew that). Cross-culturally, the placebo changes. Placebo effects are culturally-bounded.

An example: In eastern Chad traditional healers from Darfur told me that they cured “madness” (majnun) by writing Koranic verses on a tablet of wood with charcoal, then washing the tablet and making the patient drink the water that they washed the tablet with (which presumably holds the power of the verses as well as charcoal dust and whatever else was on the wooden tablet). Do patients get better? Some seem to, at least a little bit, in the short term. Would anyone reading this blog get better in a similar situation? Probably not. Why? Because the placebo effect depends on whether or not you accept the practice/practitioner as medically legitimate.

Of course, with globalization, healing practices are not necessarily unique to specific medical cultures. An example from a little closer to home: In the clinic where I work in New York, which serves patients from all over the world, we find that patients from countries where psychology is not known as a mode to treat common mental disorders often need a lot of convincing that counseling will help them in order for it to stick. Counseling is still a pretty culturally-bounded practice — culturally-bounded within Western medical culture. However, prescribing pills that make them feel better (and then maybe using some evidenced based CBT or relaxation techniques) is a lot more acceptable. Taking pills to relieve symptoms is a practice that seems to have gone cross-cultural.

The challenge for those setting up health systems in cross-cultural or multicultural settings, then, is to figure out how to utilize existing service delivery modes and networks to deliver evidenced based treatments without disrupting culturally-bounded placebo effects.


7 Responses to “Placebo effects, traditional healers, and cross-cultural psychology”

  1. 1 David Levine December 19, 2009 at 1:48 am

    I think the distinction between Western evidence-based counseling and traditional healing may be particularly small in Buddhist nations. The best evidence for therapy typically involves cognitive-behavioral therapy. As best I can tell, and with some simplification, these practices typically emphasize avoiding immediate highly emotional emotional reactions by breathing deeply and thinking calm thoughts. I assume that in Cambodia, for example, a Buddhist monk or healer is much able to teach these skills than a Western-trained professional. I’d like to see such comparative research.

    • 2 andyrasmussen December 19, 2009 at 10:56 pm

      Several Buddhist practices (or at least Buddhist-like) have indeed been adopted by modern psychological practice, most notably in the area of relaxation training. Some also see Buddhist influence in the wildly popular “mindfulness” movement (maybe it’s not quite a movement, but it does seem that every time I open up a journal I see another five articles on mindfulness). Let me clear something up though: it is not the point of cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), nor of relaxation techniques for that matter, to avoid anything. In fact, most CBTs aimed at anxiety disorders (for which they are very effective) are explicit about getting the patient to stop avoiding. However, that doesn’t negate your point about Buddhist practices being important.

      Incidentally, when I was evaluating TPO Cambodia last summer, the Khmer counselors told me that most many of their patients really identified with the relaxation techniques because they were so similar to Buddhist meditation. One counselor later added that this was in contrast to their comfort with CBT, which uses what is essentially Socratic questioning. Asking questions was not particularly polite in Khmer culture. That’s not to say that CBT didn’t work, only that we can arrive in a culture with an intervention, and have only half of it be culturally syntonic.

  2. 3 Wes Yoshimori August 25, 2011 at 10:48 am

    Hey, Thank you for the post. I enjoyed reading it. Bookmarked your page! Have a nice day.

  3. 4 frida g October 30, 2011 at 2:24 pm

    this placebo thing is basically faith that is taught in the bible. You pray for what you want, you have the vision of how you will feel and be, and you believe that vision. I have applied this to myself by reading the bible and looking up with God promises about healing. In Oct 2010 i was told that within 3 months i would come crawling for a bone fusion. I applied my faith in my situation. Tomorrow is the 1st november 2011 and i never had a need to go crawling back for any operation. Praise God he sent Christ and the holy spirit to heal us. Just need to tap into them and faith.

    • 5 andyrasmussen November 15, 2011 at 6:06 pm

      Well, maybe… but you realize that this analogy implies that faith is baseless. Placebos have no inherent healing properties, so are essentially baseless. Saying that placebos are like faith therefore implies that faith is baseless, i.e., based on nothing. Somehow I don’t think that’s what you are trying to imply.

  4. 6 Maguire May 6, 2012 at 11:38 am

    Thanks for the article. Very informative. It’d be great to have some references for the studies you refer to so that readers could look a little more deeply into them. Thanks again.

  1. 1 Belly of the Beast » Your spiritual healer is only a sign away Trackback on March 2, 2011 at 2:03 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

December 2009
« Nov   Jan »

%d bloggers like this: